MLP were instructed by the Brimpton Common Residents’ Group (BCRG) who were granted Rule 6 status to take a full part in a Public Inquiry. The case related to an unauthorised residential site for 1 gypsy pitch in West Berkshire Council, which was refused planning permission in April 2024, and was served an Enforcement Notice in August 2024.
Aaron Smith (MLP Director) gave evidence at the Inquiry relating to whether the site was a suitable location; whether the proposal would ensure public safety (due to the proximity to AWE Aldermaston); need and supply; alternatives; intentional unauthorised development; precedent; and the planning balance.
The Inspector (Mr McGlone) dismissed both appeals. In relation to the planning appeal, the Inspector held that the proposal would not accord with the development plan when read as a whole. The development would also set a precedent and there has been intentional unauthorised development. Conflicts existed with the Framework and Planning Policy for Traveller Sites. Other considerations, including the Appellant’s personal circumstances and best interests of the children did not justify a planning permission for a permanent or temporary period.
The BCRG were also awarded their partial costs for the appeal due to the Appellant’s unreasonable behaviour on both substantive and procedural matters.
This has been a worrying issue for the residents as allowing development on one plot would have created a precedent for the other plots in the field. A point understood by the Inspector.
The BCRG were also represented by Ben Fullbrook of Landmark Chambers and Elizabeth Bryant of Bryant Landscape Planning. Three local residents also gave evidence.
